Arthur's Pizzeria

Nestled in the heart of New Lothrop, MI, Arthur’s Pizzeria is a charming family-owned pizza restaurant that surprises guests with its exceptional flavors and friendly atmosphere. Though the seating area is on the cozier side, the warm hospitality and mouthwatering menu more than make up for it, creating a wonderful spot for both quick dinners and relaxed family meals.

Arthur’s Pizzeria offers a diverse menu that extends beyond just pizza, making it a delightful choice for any craving. Their pizza specials are a standout, featuring options like the Family Pack or Two Large Pizzas that promise generous portions perfect for sharing. The pizza crust is consistently praised for its crispy, perfectly balanced texture, complementing the rich and tangy sauce that’s been clearly crafted with care. Topping combinations such as bacon and pepperoni add savory depth, while the cheese bread sticks provide a wonderfully buttery, melty sidekick that customers love.

But Arthur's doesn’t stop at pizza. Their basket meals are a comforting treat, with options like Fried or Grilled Chicken Sandwich & Fries and Chicken Fingers with a warm roll, delivering crispy, flavorful bites that satisfy any appetite. For lighter or kid-friendly options, their Kids Meals cover classic favorites such as hamburgers, cheeseburgers, hot dogs, and chicken strips, making it a welcoming choice for families.

What truly makes dining at Arthur’s special is the genuine care and attention from the staff, with customers noting standout service that makes every visit feel personal. One guest raved about the attentive service of Miya, highlighting the warm, down-to-earth feel that complements the delicious food. Another mentioned the delightful cream cheese dip and the surprisingly fresh Asian chicken salad—unique additions that showcase the restaurant’s commitment to variety and quality.

Whether you’re indulging in a large pizza paired with bread sticks for a cozy night in or popping in for a quick bite of their juicy, olive-laden burger, Arthur’s Pizzeria delivers satisfaction beyond what one might expect from a small-town eatery. The flavors here evoke a comforting, homemade vibe that keeps patrons coming back, inviting you to experience the approachable yet thoughtfully prepared dishes firsthand.

For those discovering New Lothrop or locals seeking a dependable spot that combines scrumptious food with a warm community feel, Arthur’s Pizzeria is a gem worth visiting. From the crackling crust to the savory sides and heartfelt service, this pizza place turns simple meals into memorable moments.